Simply Nourish Dog Food: A Comprehensive Product Review

simply nourish dog food

Did you know 36 percent of American households have a dog? In fact, Americans spent about $71 billion on their pets alone! It goes without saying we love our dogs and would do anything to keep them happy and healthy, including keeping up with their diets. Diet directly impacts your dog's digestive system, and believe it or not, his mood. It could be overwhelming to figure out which dog food is the best to give your faithful companion, but that's why we will look at Simply Nourish dog food and then compare it to three other popular brands.

What Is Simply Nourish Dog Food?

Simply Nourish dog food is a brand that is only sold by PetSmart with goals to provide an inexpensive but natural recipe. Their parent manufacturer is American Nutrition, which has been around since 1972, and consistently meets USDA, FDA, and AAFCO standards. Simply Nourish dog food offers recipes for puppies, adults, and senior dogs, and specific lines for those with dietary preferences.

Important Ingredients

Some ingredients in Simply Nourish dog food are impressive, such as chicken, chicken meal, dried carrots, dried sweet potato, dried pumpkin, and other vitamins and minerals.

Pricing

Simply Nourish can be purchased from PetSmart for around $40 for a 30-pound bag of dry kibble. Other sizes available at PetSmart are 9-pound bags and 15-pound bags.

How It Compares

We picked a few similar products available on the market to see how they compare. To do this fairly, we will analyze and discuss Simply Nourish dog food, Rachael Ray's Nutrish, Purina Beyond Simply 9 Natural Limited Ingredient, and Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula's ingredient lists, taste factors, and health benefits, and then summarize the pros and cons of each brand.

  • Rachael Ray Nutrish Natural Dry Dog Food
  • Purina Beyond Simply 9 Natural Limited Ingredient, Adult Dry Dog Food
  • Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Dry Dog Food
Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Dry Dog Food - Natural, Chicken &...
  • One bag of Simply Nourish Small Breed Adult Dog Food - Chicken and Brown Rice Recipe and Especiales Cosas Mixing Spatula...
  • This small breed adult dog food comes packaged in a 6 pound bag
  • One 7 inch Especiales Cosas plastic mixing spatula (colors may vary). The spatula can be used for mixing water in with...
  • Ingredients
  • Taste
  • Health Benefits

We like that there are different products within the Simply Nourish dog food line, like limited ingredient, puppies or senior diets, weight loss, and size-specific formulas. This shows that Simply Nourish is all-inclusive which makes it easier when starting your puppy out on this brand and following through adulthood. We broke down the protein, fat, and carbohydrate levels.

  • Protein: 29 out of 100 percent
  • Fat: 18 out of 100 percent
  • Carbohydrate: 45 out of 100 percent

We've found that Simply Nourish dog food has a near-average protein, below-average fat, and near-average carbs when compared to a typical dry dog food.

Pros

  • Great ingredient list
  • Versatile flavors and types of foods
  • Price is about average

Cons

  • Health benefits could be better
  • Only purchasable through PetSmart or Chewy.com
Rachael Ray Nutrish Natural Dry Dog Food, Real Chicken & Veggies...
  • U.S. Farm-Raised Chicken is the #1 Ingredient
  • Natural Prebiotics Help Support Healthy Digestion
  • No Artificial Flavors or Artificial Preservatives

Features

Rachael Ray Nutrish was designed by celebrity chef Rachael Ray. She partnered up with manufacturer Ainsworth Pet Nutrition with intentions to develop a formula for her own pit bull and promises that a portion of the proceeds goes to Rachael's Rescue, which is a nonprofit organization to donate to shelters for at-risk dogs and other pet charities.

  • price
  • Ingredients
  • Taste
  • Health Benefits

We broke down the protein, fat, and carbohydrate levels.

  • Protein: 30 out of 100 percent
  • Fat: 16 out of 100 percent
  • Carbohydrate: 47 out of 100 percent

Rachael Ray Nutrish is not too different from Simply Nourish dog food. After analysis, we've found that this is near-average protein, near-average fat, and near-average carbs when compared to a typical dry dog food. However, Rachael Ray Nutrish goes beyond this line. She has 5 lines which are Nutrish, Dish, Just 6, Zero Grain, and Peak. We like how inclusive and broad the variety of Rachael Ray's brands are.

Pros

  • The price is right
  • Portion of proceeds goes to pet charities
  • Text...

Cons

  • Ingredient list has too many questionable ingredients
  • Health benefits could be better
Sale
Purina Beyond Simply 9 Natural Limited Ingredient, Chicken & Barley...
  • 24 Lb. Bag - Purina Beyond Simply 9 White Meat Chicken & Whole Barley Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food
  • Packaging May Vary
  • Real Chicken Is The #1 Ingredient

Features

Purina is the world's second-largest and the nation's most well-known pet supplier. Purina manufactures dog and cat food, dog and cat toys, cat litter, and other dog and cat accessories. Its parent company is Nestle, which owns other brands like Beneful, Friskies, and Purina ONE. Purina has had a rocky history with many recalls, salmonella outbreaks, false advertisements, and even reports of pets dying after consuming certain treats.

  • price
  • Ingredients
  • Taste
  • Health Benefits

Though many might not know this, dogs often develop an allergy to chicken. This formula is fine for those dogs that do well with chicken, but definitely not recommended for those who get sick or develop a skin irritation after consuming chicken-based formulas. We broke down the protein, fat, and carbohydrate levels.

  • Protein: 30 out of 100 percent
  • Fat: 18 out of 100 percent
  • Carbohydrate: 44 out of 100 percent

After analysis, we've found that Simply 9 has a near-average protein, above-average fat, and below-average carbs when compared to a typical dry dog food.

Pros

  • Simply 9 is one of Purina's best brands
  • The price is fair
  • Can be found at almost any store that sells pet supplies

Cons

  • The company has dealt with a number of lawsuits and outbreaks
  • Health benefits could be better
Sale
Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Adult Dog Food – Natural Dry...
  • HIGH QUALITY DOG FOOD: Blue Buffalo always features real meat as the 1st ingredient. High-quality, protein from Deboned...
  • ADULT DOG FOOD: BLUE Life Protection Formula dog food for adult dogs contains essential proteins and carbohydrates to...
  • HEALTHY DOG FOOD: BLUE Life Protection Formula Dog Food contains exclusive LifeSource Bits - unique dry dog food kibble...

Features

Blue Buffalo was founded by Bill and Jackie Bishop when their terrier, named Blue, came down with a range of health issues. This inspired the couple to create a line of dog food that was affordable, commercially available, and rich with nutrients. However, Blue Buffalo has been under scrutiny for a lawsuit with Purina after being sued for claiming to have whole meat-based ingredients but, after testing, was found to contain by-product meals. Blue Buffalo also has voluntarily recalled one of its products for containing unusually high beef thyroid hormones.

  • price
  • Ingredients
  • Taste
  • Health Benefits

Blue Buffalo Life Protection is made with “LifeSource bits,” a name dubbed by Blue Buffalo that are specially formulated bits of food that contain a blend of healthy ingredients like whole grains, antioxidants, vegetables, vitamins, and minerals. This is a major plus to the brand's food. We broke down the protein, fat, and carbohydrate levels.

  • Protein: 27 out of 100 percent
  • Fat: 16 out of 100 percent
  • Carbohydrate: 50 out of 100 percent

After analysis, we've found that Blue Buffalo Life Protection has near-average protein, near-average fat, and above-average carbs when compared to a typical dry dog food.

Pros

  • Infused with LifeSource bits
  • Price is just right
  • Can buy anywhere pet food is sold

Cons

  • Has a history of recalls and misleading consumers about ingredients
  • Health benefits could be better

Our Verdict

We know that there are hundreds of brands you could choose from, which is why we chose some of the most popular brands that are commercially available for the lowest prices. Simply Nourish, Rachael Ray's Nutrish, Purina, and Blue Buffalo were analyzed and rated for quality based on their ingredients, taste variety, and overall health benefits considering protein, fat, and carbohydrate levels.

When considering all these factors, we've concluded that the highest-rated dog food is Simply Nourish dog food. After researching some company and manufacturer's background, Simply Nourish is constantly meeting standards and guidelines, has never suffered from recalls or been in the spotlight for legal issues, and has the most impressive list of ingredients and health benefits out of the four we've rated today.

However, we also really love Rachael Ray Nutrish because of the charitable donations that go to at-risk dogs and other pet shelters. The Nutrish ingredient list and health benefits were almost the same as Simply Nourish dog food, so we must give Nutrish an honorable mention. Unfortunately, brands like Purina and Blue Buffalo must be automatically disqualified for their health complaints.

There are 69 million dogs in households all across America and is also the world's most popular pet. It's easy to see that there is nothing but truth to saying that a dog is a man's best friend, so why not feed him like one?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here